JHVEPhoto/iStock Editorial through Getty Photos
Scenario Overview
On Friday after the market closed, the FCC issued a Listening to Designation Order associated to the proposed acquisition of Tegna (NYSE:TGNA) by Commonplace Basic. The FCC’s resolution is predicated on the two predominant problems with retransmission charge improve and native information job cuts, regardless of Commonplace Basic’s assurances on the contrary. Whereas the FCC has not utterly blocked the deal, the Listening to Designation Order requires the events to current their case in entrance of an Administrative Regulation Decide, though a date has not been specified. This method is commonly utilized by the FCC to successfully halt a deal, because the uncertainty surrounding the timeline is usually a deterrent for each events, significantly in gentle of the accruing every day ticking payment. Tegna and Commonplace Basic might select to increase the surface date of the deal, although this has not been confirmed.
For my part, the more than likely final result is that Tegna and Commonplace Basic will determine to terminate the proposed transaction. For the reason that FCC issued a Listening to Designation Order, Tegna has the appropriate to terminate the deal and accumulate a $136 million termination payment, which is what I anticipate will occur. For Commonplace Basic, it’s of their finest curiosity to stroll away from the deal, given that every passing month ends in extra ticking charges of $0.125 per share, or $1.5 per share for 12 months.
As a aspect be aware, I beforehand prompt a protracted bond and brief inventory commerce in gentle of this case, and I consider buyers who adopted this suggestion ought to have weathered the state of affairs comparatively unscathed. This underscores the importance of hedging in eventualities with binary outcomes.
Technicals
Let’s begin by analyzing the technical features of the state of affairs. Tegna’s inventory has dropped from Friday’s shut of $21.84 to $16.30, and it is unsure the place the optimum deal break worth must be. From early 2019 to early 2020 (pre-COVID), the inventory was buying and selling within the vary of $15-17 per share, though this may not be the unaffected worth as a result of rumors of Apollo’s curiosity in shopping for Tegna in February 2019. There could also be extra promoting stress from Commonplace Basic as they liquidate their holdings in Tegna, though they may probably purchase extra as effectively. It is also unclear what quantity of the float is held by the chance arbitrage group, given the excessive diploma of regulatory danger within the present state of affairs (I personally suppose it is low as a result of the regulatory danger is simply too excessive). Consequently, there could also be a rotation of Tegna’s shareholder base within the close to future, till the worth falls sufficiently to draw extra fundamental-based buyers.
Fundamentals
Tegna from a elementary investor’s perspective, I am very snug with Tegna’s state of affairs. Like different publicly-traded TV broadcasting firms, Tegna generates most of its income via promoting and retransmission, with a roughly equal cut up between the 2. Retransmission income is the payment that cable operators pay to hold an area broadcasting station’s sign, and is predicated on a $/subscriber/month foundation. Broadcasting stations can negotiate charge will increase over time, and there are nonetheless many viewers preferring to look at native information on TV. Twine-cutting has been a problem for broadcasting stations, however the impression has been much less extreme than anticipated as a result of a rising subscriber base of digital MVPDs, corresponding to YouTube TV. Retransmission income is recurring, sticky, and rising from charge will increase, which offsets the extra cyclical promoting income.
Promoting income is self-explanatory, with Tegna promoting TV promoting slots between and through reveals. The corporate receives alerts from broadcasting networks and dietary supplements them with native information produced by Tegna, leading to promoting slots shared between the community and Tegna. Broadcasting networks promote nationwide promoting, whereas native broadcasting stations promote native promoting. Though promoting income is cyclical, Tegna advantages from political promoting each two years, which offers a windfall. Native TV stays some of the efficient methods for politicians to achieve a broad viewers, and this can be a pure margin for Tegna as there are few extra prices related to political promoting income.
Tegna’s prices embody funds to broadcasting stations for the sign, generally known as reverse compensation or reverse retransmission income, which is a mixture of fastened charges and $/sub/month relying on the community. Different working bills are principally fastened in nature, offering Tegna with a big working leverage, particularly throughout election years.
Lastly, Tegna has among the finest stability sheets in its comp group, with internet leverage of roughly 2.6x. The corporate has stability of predictable retransmission income, cyclical promoting income, and periodic windfall from political income. It generates substantial free money circulation and maintains a conservative stability sheet.
Valuation
My valuation of Tegna is predicated on the FY2024 EBITDA, which I adjusted utilizing a decrease EV/EBITDA a number of as a result of the corporate will “over-earn” in 2024, a presidential election 12 months. I’ve estimated the FY2024 retransmission income at $1.65 billion, political income at $475 million, and promoting income at $1.3 billion. With an EBITDA margin of 36%, I arrive at an estimated FY2024 EBITDA of roughly $1.224 billion. Utilizing a cyclical trough a number of of 6.0x towards internet debt of roughly $2.8 billion, my goal worth for Tegna is $20.60 per share.
For context, I anticipate Tegna’s retransmission income to be round $1.5 billion for FY2022, with subsequent negotiations driving the speed improve by greater than 5% yearly to achieve $1.65 billion by FY2024. The corporate generated $445.5 million in political income over the past presidential election 12 months. I’ve additionally assumed an 8% decline in promoting income. Whereas the FY2020 EBITDA margin was roughly 35.5%. Given the upper political income, I’ve factored in a 0.5% margin enlargement.
As a aspect be aware, though I do not get pleasure from detailed due diligence that Commonplace Basic performed, I can perceive how they may underwrite this funding at $24 per share (with my truthful worth near $21, plus some management premium) – whereas $24 could also be a full worth for Tegna on a managed foundation, the corporate’s money circulation technology capability and the windfall from political promoting income each two years will allow Tegna to pay down debt comparatively shortly, provided that it generates $400-700 million in free money circulation yearly.
Conclusion
It is unlucky that regardless of Commonplace Basic’s finest efforts, the FCC nonetheless blocked the well-negotiated transaction between the 2 events. Whereas the deal is technically nonetheless on the desk, I anticipate that each events will in the end stroll away from it. Maybe one other purchaser will emerge within the close to future, provided that a number of events have proven curiosity in Tegna over the previous few years. Within the meantime, I consider that the asset worth has not deteriorated and that Tegna is value not less than $20 per share based mostly on fundamentals, and $24 per share in a take-private transaction. Though there could also be volatility forward, I’d argue that $16.30 will not be a horrible entry worth for value-oriented, long-term-focused buyers.
